The much-anticipated Andor series, a prequel to Rogue One, it's safe to say, had been a polarizing experience for Star Wars fans. While some have praised its slow-burn approach, intricate world-building, and nuanced characters, others have found it to be a tedious and unnecessary addition to the Star Wars universe.
One of the main criticisms of Andor is its pacing. The series takes its time to establish the characters and their motivations, which can be frustrating for viewers who are used to the fast-paced action of other Star Wars properties. The plot also meanders at times, with seemingly pointless subplots and detours that do little to advance the overall narrative.
Another issue is the lack of connection to the wider Star Wars universe. While the series does feature some familiar faces and references to events from the films, it often feels disconnected from the grander scheme of things. This can be alienating for fans who are looking for a more traditional Star Wars experience.
The characters, while well-acted and complex, are not particularly memorable or engaging. Cassian Andor, the titular protagonist, is a morally ambiguous figure who is difficult to root for. The supporting cast is equally bland, with few characters leaving a lasting impression.
The series does have its merits. The production values are high, with impressive visuals and detailed sets. The performances are also solid, with Diego Luna delivering a nuanced portrayal of Cassian Andor. However, these positive aspects are not enough to compensate for the series' flaws.
In conclusion, Andor Season 1 is a mixed bag. It is a slow-burn spy thriller that may appeal to some viewers, but it is ultimately a disappointing and unnecessary addition to the Star Wars universe. The series' pacing, lack of connection to the wider Star Wars universe, and unengaging characters make it a chore to watch. While the production values and performances are commendable, they are not enough to save the series from mediocrity.
Fans who are looking for a more traditional Star Wars experience may want to give Andor a miss. However, those who are willing to be patient and invest in the series' slow-burn approach may find something to appreciate.
P.S. Andor Season 2 is in the works but may not be released till 2025! Unusual for there to be almost 3 year gap between seasons but draw your own conclusions.