In "Presumed Innocent" Part 4, we witness a further decline in Rusty's character and an increasing sense of hopelessness surrounding his case. While the performances of the leads, particularly those portraying Rusty (Jake Gyllenhaal) and his wife Barbara (Ruth Negga), remain compelling, the material they're working with leaves much to be desired.
Rusty continues to prove himself unlikeable, even repellent. He's portrayed as an arrogant, narcissistic adulterer with a volatile temper, traits that don't exactly endear him to the audience. His interactions with his son, a potential witness, and the DA's office only serve to paint him in an even harsher light.
As a viewer, it's becoming increasingly difficult to root for Rusty. His actions and demeanor suggest guilt rather than innocence, and the narrative hasn't provided enough reason to sympathize with his plight. Halfway through the miniseries, it feels as though Rusty is doomed, both in terms of his legal case and his relationship with the audience.
The writing, surprisingly for an industry veteran like David E. Kelley, feels lackluster. Rusty's character development is stagnant, and the plot lacks the intrigue necessary to keep viewers invested. The lack of empathy for Rusty is a significant issue, as it makes it hard to care about his exoneration.
The miniseries desperately needs a turning point. Either Rusty's circumstances must change drastically, or his personality needs a significant shift to make him a more relatable and sympathetic character. As it stands, "Presumed Innocent" is a disappointing watch with little to recommend it.
What do you think of Presumed Innocent so far? Are you able to root for Rusty’s cause? Leave your thoughts in the comments below.